Ever since the Big 10 announced that they were going to more actively seek a 12th member a few months ago, rumors have run rampant about not only who that school may be, but also realignment amongst all the other conferences. The domino affect of a team changing conferences and moving into the Big 10 would not have to happen if Notre Dame would sacrifice its status as an independent team in football, but they have stated multiple times that they have no desire to do so. The other logical teams that have been brought up are regional teams like Missouri and Pittsburgh, as well as teams that may expand their presence into different markets, such as Syracuse and Rutgers. The most recent rumor has the Big 10 having preliminary talks with Texas.... yes, Texas. Here's the case as I see it:
Why Texas would do this:
The Big 10 would provide increased revenues from the conference, mostly as a result of the Big 10 network, which I believe was the first conference network and is the most widely distributed. The Big 10 is also a stronger conference in terms of academics, which always helps with those people that think these kids go to school to get an education. The Big 10 also provides for some intriguing match-ups in terms of competition with the likes of Ohio State, Penn State, and Michigan (should they get back to glory). The most intriguing part of the competition is that Texas has to feel as though they could win that conference every year. Much of the Big 12 gets Texas talent, some of the best in the country, but little of the Big 10 does, and with the (perceived) weakness of the Big 10, Texas has to think they could possibly win the conference and thus be in competition for the National Championship every year.
Why Texas wouldn't do this:
The first is the natural rivalries within the Big 12 conference. The Texas A&M rivalry has the longest history, but the Oklahoma game has become one of, if not the, biggest rivalry games in all of college football, and no doubt brings huge revenues in itself to Texas. Texas would also have to balance the cost of traveling within the conference, not only for football, but all 20-30 (maybe more) sports. These costs would have to be more than matched in the increased revenues. The other consideration, though it may not be as big, is the effects on recruiting. Now, Texas has never had problems recruiting, in Texas all they have to do is offer and the kid seems to come. However, in following recruiting I see that kids frequently refer to wanting to play in fill-in-the-blank conference, and that is frequently geographical. As most conferences stand, they are mostly geographical, though there is certainly no rule that they have to. Whether a conference change would affect recruiting, I guess we won't know until it happens, but I think it's possible. The perceived lesser competition could be viewed as a negative as well, so that may play against joining the Big 10 as well.
Ultimately, I don't see Texas doing it. I don't think they'd give up the rivalries, and I think the Big 12 will make an effort to keep them around. In addition, the Big 12 network is likely growing, as it is fairly young at this point, and could bring greater revenues soon. The geographic aspect obviously doesn't make a whole lot of sense either. But who am I kidding? I'm a Nebraska, if the Big 10 wants them, they can have 'em.
1 comments:
Go Hawks.
Post a Comment